[Using a broad definition of D&D to include all editions, retro-clones, etc.]
I started with the blue dragon, had the white box LBB, but really grew up on AD&D Efreeti and Gem Eyes. Played some in highschool and college. Then 2ed splat mania + too many crap products + (in retrospect) the shift in style, structure, and substance of those products as compared to 1ed era drove me from D&D (into other RPGs).
I returned to D&D a little after 3.5 release. I've since run and played enough of OD&D(Swords & Wizardry), Basic(Labyrinth Lord), AD&D(OSRIC), 3.5, and 4ed to arrive at the following opinion.
AD&D including (and even more so) 2ed is my least favorite edition of D&D to run/play. This was news to me as it's the edition I've played and run the most. The DMG is still a good resource and many of the classic modules I'll try to weave into campaigns. But, I won't be using AD&D rules to run them.
AD&D and it's clones are just so horribly fiddly, filled with wildly inconsistent levels of simulation and detail. Baroque were simple would suffice, vague or abstract were a little more is needed. Too many "broken" classes, combos and rules. It's the shored up, chronically patched half-way house between the wild and loose "earlier" systems and the mechanistic edifices to game theory of later editions.
There's a reason we have sayings along the lines of "right tool for the right job", "do one thing and do it well", "don't try to be all things to all people". It's cause of people like me.
I enjoy the ends of the spectrum. Where games, successful or not at getting there, at least know what they want to be. Sometimes I crave a fine dark chocolate. Sometimes an oily, 100% natural nut butter, the type that requires stirring. But, my desire for a waxy chocolate covered peanut like fudge thing is quite low.
All Time Most Popular Posts
[ Magic Items Should be Magical originally posted Dec 25th, 2008! A good post, edited and shortened a bit.] Magic Items Are Special Creat...
[This post was written by Flip, author of The Paradigm Traveller RPG blog. Payback for the guest post Role Playing Game aides and accoute...
Badger, Badger, Badger, Badger, Badger, MUSHROOM!
or d6+6. Some high number of hit points. Pixie being a Player Character version of some 6-8 inch tall thing with wings that flits about an...
In my Gold and Glory campaign I've created some fluff around standard D&D magic. Which has lead to particular research rules I us...
Dicecreator posted video update to my DIY Dice post, nice! Looks awesome, thanks for the video.
"In print" includes in PDF. "1st Edition AD&D" includes OSRIC. To compliment your recently acquired 1st Editi...
Awhile back friend, who had just seen Mad Max (a great disappointment btw), was bugging me to run a post apocalyptic campaign every time he ...
Oh giditty git, I loves me some maps. "Atlas" was my favorite book type as a kid. They were bigger than any other book in our hou...
Omg this game is so awesome I don't mind being chewed on. I'm predisposed to like DCC RPG , I'm biased, Troll and Flame was...